Cases Considered: Dunsmuir v. New Brunswick, 2008 SCC 9
PDF Version: The Metaphysical Court: Dunsmuir v. New Brunswick and the Standard of Review
Introduction
The standard used by courts to review administrative decision-making is of central importance to energy and resource development law. Key decisions about regulation of utilities, supervision of energy markets, development of energy projects and facilities, and environmental obligations imposed on resource development, are authorized by legislation, and made and implemented by regulatory authorities. While for the most part, most of the time, the focus of everyone involved is simply on the making and implementing of those regulatory decisions, the courts retain the constitutional power to review and ultimately control this exercise of regulatory authority. Thus, the question of how the courts will exercise that power – the level of deference they will employ and how willing they will be to override regulatory decision-makers – is the fundamental backdrop against which these decisions are made.