Category Archives: Costs

Standing at the ERCB without an interest in land, but “no costs for you!”

Case considered: Freehold Petroleum and Natural Gas Owners Association v. Alberta (Energy Resources Conservation Board), 2010 ABCA 125

In Freehold Petroleum and Natural Gas Owners Association, Madam Justice Elizabeth McFayden dismisses an application for leave to appeal an Energy Resources Conservation Board (ERCB) hearing costs decision that relates to an earlier ERCB decision concerning a mineral lease dispute. This Court of Appeal decision and the underlying ERCB decisions are noteworthy to me for two reasons: (1) the ERCB granted full hearing participation rights to the Freehold Petroleum and Natural Gas Owners Association (the Freehold Owners Association) despite the fact it does not have an interest in land; and (2) the Court of Appeal defers to the ERCB on what I consider to be an unreasonable exercise of its discretion on the costs matter. I will comment on each of these points in turn after briefly summarizing the facts.

Continue reading →

Cost Decision in the Human Rights Case of Lund v. Boissoin

Case considered: Boissoin v. Lund, 2010 ABQB 123

PDF version: Cost Decision in the Human Rights Case of Lund v. Boissoin

There are several ABlawg posts written about the human rights case involving Dr. Darren Lund’s complaint to the Alberta Human Rights Commission (see here). The case concerned the publication in the Red Deer Advocate of a letter to the editor written by Stephen Boissoin, which Dr. Lund alleged violated s.3 of Alberta’s Human Rights, Citizenship and Multiculturalism Act, R.S.A. 2000, c. H-14 (“HRCMA“, recently re-enacted as the Alberta Human Rights Act, R.S.A. 2000, c. A-25.5 (“AHRA“)). Justice Earl Wilson recently issued a Memorandum of Decision on the issue of costs.

Continue reading →