Category Archives: COVID-19

Alberta’s Vaccine Passport System: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

By: Lorian Hardcastle and Shaun Fluker

PDF Version: Alberta’s Vaccine Passport System: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

Matters Commented On: Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH) Order 42-2021 and CMOH Order 43-2021

Good governance practices by the executive branch in how it addresses COVID-19 have largely been absent throughout the pandemic across Canada, but surely we have hit a new low in Alberta with what transpired last week. Facing criticism from the public, pleas from health care professionals, and a health care system straining under the increasing number of hospitalizations, the Premier reappeared at a September 15 press conference after a lengthy hiatus, along with the Minister of Health, the Chief Medical Officer of Health, and the CEO of Alberta Health Services. The Premier was questioned about the termination of public health restrictions in early July and the decision to move towards treating COVID-19 as endemic by largely eliminating basic public health measures like testing, tracing, and isolating (a decision that the government later backpedalled on). Although the Premier was initially apologetic for ending public health restrictions in an effort to enjoy the “best summer ever,” he later stated that “I don’t apologize for the decision to relax public health restrictions in the summer….” For her part, the CMOH has admitted that July’s decisions, which were based on her recommendations, put Alberta on its devastating fourth wave trajectory and has said that she “deeply” regrets contributing to the narrative that COVID-19 was over. Continue reading →

COVID-19 and Enforcement of Public Health Orders

By: Shaun Fluker

PDF Version: COVID-19 and Enforcement of Public Health Orders 

Legislation Commented On: Procedures (Public Health) Amendment Regulation, Alta Reg 92/2021

This amendment to the Procedures Regulation, Alta Reg 63/2017, was recently made by the Lieutenant Governor in Council with Order in Council 124/2021 (May 5, 2021). The amendment raises the specified penalty (the violation ticket amount) from $1000 to $2000 for contravention of a Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH) public health order issued under section 29 of the Public Health Act, RSA 2000, c P-37. The amendment came into force on May 19, 2021. This is the fine payable by a person who chooses to plead guilty (see Part 2 of the Provincial Offences Procedure Act, RSA 2000, c P-34) for such things as not wearing a mask where required, gathering in large groups outside, allowing non-family members into their home, or not keeping two metres apart from others. Premier Kenney announced the increased fine on May 4 during the initial ‘Stop the Spike’ announcement where the Premier also warned Albertans that section 73 of the Public Health Act provides for a penalty as high as $100,000 for a first offence in these matters. This is part of Alberta’s response to calls for stronger enforcement on non-compliance with COVID-19 public health orders. The third wave of this pandemic gave us a full display of just how inadequate the bare threat of legal enforcement is towards ensuring compliance with these rules. This deficiency in the authoritative punch of COVID-19 public health orders is also the reason why Alberta (and other provinces) went to the extreme measure of obtaining an injunction from the Court of Queen’s Bench to prohibit the very public and orchestrated violations of COVID-19 public health orders. While politicians across Canada begin to engage in what might end up being a foolhardy race to be the first jurisdiction to end COVID-19 restrictions (Premier Kenney announced Alberta’s ambitious Open for Summer Plan on May 26 – just three weeks after announcing tougher enforcement measures), it would be wise for these lawmakers to pause, reflect, and heed some lessons from the compliance and enforcement mess associated with their COVID-19 public health orders. Continue reading →

Proposed Amendments to the Public Health Act Confirm (Retroactively?) the Validity of the Chief Medical Officer of Health’s COVID-19 Legislation

By: Shaun Fluker and Lorian Hardcastle

PDF Version: Proposed Amendments to the Public Health Act Confirm (Retroactively?) the Validity of the Chief Medical Officer of Health’s COVID-19 Legislation

Bill Commented On: Bill 66, Public Health Amendment Act, 2021, 2nd Sess, 30th Leg, Alberta, 2021 (first reading 12 April 2021)

On April 12, the Minister of Health tabled Bill 66, the Public Health Amendment Act, 2021, in the Legislative Assembly for first reading. This Bill proposes amendments to the Public Health Act, RSA 2000, c P-37, on matters such as the qualifications for public health officials, developing plans to address chronic disease and injury prevention, the privacy of certain public health records, and decriminalizing the inhalation of intoxicants. As we discuss in this post, the Bill also proposes to address governance issues associated with the exercise of legislative powers by medical officers of health and Ministers under the Act, issues that have previously been identified on ABlawg (see e.g. here, here, and here). These amendments are a step in the right direction, but far more needs to be done to preserve the rule of law during exceptional times where executive rule by fiat has been uncomfortably normalized within a democracy.

Continue reading →

COVID-19 and Cabinet Secrets

By: Shaun Fluker

PDF Version: COVID-19 and Cabinet Secrets

Matter Commented On: CMOH Order 38-2020

The Opposition is calling for the release of public health recommendations made by the Chief Medical Officer of Health to cabinet which informed the decision announced on November 24 to declare a second public health emergency and to impose enhanced measures to contain the spread of COVID-19. These enhanced measures are described at COVID-19 info for Albertans: Mandatory public health measures and those which came into force on November 24 are set out in CMOH Order 38-2020. In response to questions from the media at the November 26 update, both the Minister of Health and the Chief Medical Officer of Health stated the recommendations cannot be disclosed because of cabinet confidence – a constitutional convention in a Westminster government which keeps cabinet deliberations in secret for purposes of governance (see here for a discussion of these important functions). This convention is also codified in section 22 of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, RSA 2000, c F-25. What does the common law say on this?

Continue reading →

COVID-19 and Rule by Fiat under Alberta’s Public Health Act

By: Shaun Fluker and Lorian Hardcastle

PDF Version: COVID-19 and Rule by Fiat under Alberta’s Public Health Act

Matters Commented On: Order in Council 354/2020, CMOH Order 38-2020, and COVID-19 info for Albertans: Mandatory public health measures

Alberta declared its second COVID-19 related public health emergency on November 24 with Order in Council 354/2020, which was issued under section 52.1 of the Public Health Act, RSA 2000, c P-37 (the Act). This declaration is in place for 90 days, unless extended by resolution of the legislature pursuant to section 52.8 of the Act. This declaration also reinstates the controversial power of ministers to unilaterally amend statutes (see here) over the holiday season. On the same day as this declaration, the Premier, the Minister of Health, and the Chief Medical Officer of Health announced new restrictions to “bend the curve” at a news conference. The Premier and the Minister of Health stated that many of the new restrictions would take effect immediately with the backstop of legal sanction (including $1000 tickets). These measures were considered and determined without any legislative debate, despite the fact that the Legislature is currently sitting. Public debate on these new legislative measures seems to have amounted to nothing more than questions from media at the news conference. COVID-19 has many victims; democracy should not be one of them.

Continue reading →