By: Lorian Hardcastle
Legislation and Cases Commented on: Public Health Act, RSA 2000, c P-37; CM v Alberta, 2022 ABKB 716 (CanLII); Ingram v Alberta (Chief Medical Officer of Health), 2023 ABKB 453 (CanLII)
PDF Version: The Next Chapter in the Role of Alberta’s Chief Medical Officer of Health
At the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, provincial public health officials were thrust into the spotlight as trusted figures who would guide the public through the unknowns of a novel virus. However, as the pandemic raged on and tensions emerged regarding the appropriate restrictiveness of public health measures, cracks formed in the relationships between the public, politicians, and public health officials. At times, Alberta’s then Premier Jason Kenney and then Minister of Health Tyler Shandro seemed content to take credit for effectively balancing “lives and livelihoods”. However, when things were not going well, they would credit then Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH) Deena Hinshaw. For example, when the government’s disastrous “Open for Summer” plan contributed to severe hospital capacity problems and prompted discussions of sending people out of province for care and rationing essential health services, Shandro was quick to note that the plan “came from Dr. Hinshaw” and that he was “deferential to [her] independence.” Continue reading