By: Lorian Hardcastle and Shaun Fluker
Bill Commented On: Bill 6, Public Health Amendment Act, 2023, 1st Sess, 31st Leg, Alberta, 2021 (first reading 2 November 2023)
PDF Version: Haste Makes Waste: Amending the Public Health Act
If there is one point of consensus on public health decisions made in Alberta during the COVID-19 pandemic, it is probably that the Public Health Act, RSA 2000, c P-37 failed to provide a proper framework for general lawmaking by executive order. The enactment of COVID-19 public health orders that applied restrictions to the general public did not adhere to basic matters of democratic governance such as organization and clarity, predictability and consistency, transparency and justification, and accountability to the elected assembly. The Act contains no provisions to ensure these lawmaking attributes are followed in making public health orders. Indeed, just weeks after the onset of the pandemic in 2020 it was readily apparent the Act was wholly inadequate in this regard (see here and here). Instead of addressing these fundamental issues, the UCP government has been fixated on amendments that score political points. For example, in April 2021, Alberta made a number of relatively inconsequential amendments to the Act (which we discuss here), but still found space to repeal Cabinet powers to compel vaccination in a public health emergency. In this post we explain why Bill 6, Public Health Amendment Act, 2023 is more of the same.