By: Anna Lund and Sarah Buhler
Case Commented On: Heegsma v Hamilton, 2026 ONCA 726 (CanLII) rev’g 2024 ONSC 7154 (CanLII)
PDF Version: Taking Encampment Charter Claims Seriously: A Comment on Heegsma v Hamilton (2026 ONCA)
In Heegsma v Hamilton (CA), the Ontario Court of Appeal recently considered the issue of what limits the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms places on municipalities’ bylaws and enforcement actions with respect to unhoused people and their shelters. The Court of Appeal found that the magnitude of legal errors made by the trial judge required that the matter be remitted for a new hearing. Its decision addresses several important issues related to Charter-related encampment litigation and emphasizes that Charter claims by encampment residents must be treated by courts seriously and with care. The Court of Appeal decision cautions judges against summarily dismissing the evidence of unhoused affiants even when they have mental health issues, are in active addiction or have a history of using controlled substances. The Court of Appeal also emphasizes the importance of cogent reasons and a sufficient “depth of analysis” given the gravity and public importance of issues relating to encampments (CA at para 40). The trial court decision (SC) had addressed several important issues: whether section 7 of the Charter establishes a right to shelter during the daytime, whether encampment evictions violate section 15 of the Charter, and whether unhoused individuals should be granted Charter damages for their removal from encampments. The Court of Appeal decision does not include substantive decisions on these points but does provide guidance on the types of questions that must be addressed in resolving them. This case comment synthesizes these key takeaways from the Heegsma case.