Author Archives: Katherine MacKenzie

About Katherine MacKenzie

Katherine is legal counsel with the Alberta Law Reform Institute (ALRI). Her recent law reform work includes projects focused on substitute decision-making documents and international commercial arbitration.

Does the Dower Act Still Serve a Useful Purpose? ALRI Wants to Hear From You!

By: Katherine MacKenzie

PDF Version: Does the Dower Act Still Serve a Useful Purpose? ALRI Wants to Hear From You!

Legislation Commented On: Dower Act, RSA 2000, c D-15

The Alberta Law Reform Institute (ALRI) is studying whether the Dower Act should be reformed or repealed.  The project is still in its early stages, with a consultation document forthcoming in 2021. In the meantime, ALRI is seeking preliminary feedback on the Dower Act and any practical problems it may present.

Key Features of the Dower Act

The rights under the Dower Act only apply to married people (s 1(c)). The Act is intended to protect a spouse (the “dower spouse”) if the couple’s home is solely owned by the other spouse (the “owner spouse”). It applies to a “homestead”, which is a parcel of land where the owner spouse lived during the marriage (s 1(d)). The Dower Act protects the dower spouse from losing their home, either during the lifetime of the owner spouse or after the owner spouse’s death. There are two key features:

  • Consent to disposition: The owner spouse cannot dispose of a homestead without the consent of the dower spouse (s 2(1)). Disposition includes a transfer, long-term lease, or mortgage (s 1(b)). If the owner spouse disposes of a homestead without consent, they may be subject to a penalty and liable to pay damages to the dower spouse (ss 2(3), 11).
  • Life estate: The dower spouse is entitled to a life estate in the homestead after the death of the owner spouse (s 18).

The Dower Act has been part of the law of Alberta for more than 100 years, but it has not changed substantially since 1948.

Continue reading

Inter-Provincial Recognition of Substitute Decision-Making Documents: Personal Directives

By: Katherine MacKenzie

PDF Version: Inter-Provincial Recognition of Substitute Decision-Making Documents: Personal Directives

Report Commented On: Alberta Law Reform Institute, Inter-Provincial Recognition of Substitute Decision-Making Documents: Personal Directives, Final Report 113

A little over a year ago, I wrote a post about the Alberta Law Reform Institute’s (ALRI) project on the inter-provincial recognition of substitute decision-making documents. This was an implementation project, which means that it looked at whether sample, uniform legislation already researched and drafted by the Uniform Law Conference of Canada (ULCC) was suitable for enactment in Alberta.

At the time of that post, ALRI recommended that the ULCC’s uniform legislation should be implemented in Alberta, with some minor amendments. We also sought feedback on our preliminary recommendations for reform. Unfortunately, the consultation results did not support our preliminary recommendations and, as a result, ALRI is not in a position to make any final proposals. Instead, Final Report 113 summarizes the project’s consultation process and results, and highlights any policy alternatives or additional issues that may deserve further exploration and analysis.

Continue reading

Inter-Provincial Recognition of Substitute Decision-Making Documents

By: Katherine MacKenzie

PDF Version: Inter-Provincial Recognition of Substitute Decision-Making Documents

Report Commented On: Alberta Law Reform Institute, Inter-Provincial Recognition of Substitute Decision-Making Documents, Report for Discussion 32

The Alberta Law Reform Institute (ALRI) is considering changes to the statutory rules governing recognition of substitute decision-making documents (enduring powers of attorney, personal directives etc.) that originate outside of Alberta. It recently published Inter-Provincial Recognition of Substitute Decision-Making Documents, Report for Discussion 32. The report reviews the issues with the existing law, considers the uniform provisions recently proposed by the Uniform Law Conference of Canada (ULCC) and makes preliminary recommendations for reform. Before it makes final recommendations to the Alberta government, ALRI is seeking feedback on the questions and proposals below. Continue reading