University of Calgary Faculty of Law ABLawg.ca logo over mountains

Category: Charter Page 1 of 2

Taking Encampment Charter Claims Seriously: A Comment on Heegsma v Hamilton (2026 ONCA)

By: Anna Lund and Sarah Buhler

Case Commented On: Heegsma v Hamilton, 2026 ONCA 726 (CanLII) rev’g 2024 ONSC 7154 (CanLII)

PDF Version: Taking Encampment Charter Claims Seriously: A Comment on Heegsma v Hamilton (2026 ONCA)

In Heegsma v Hamilton (CA), the Ontario Court of Appeal recently considered the issue of what limits the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms places on municipalities’ bylaws and enforcement actions with respect to unhoused people and their shelters. The Court of Appeal found that the magnitude of legal errors made by the trial judge required that the matter be remitted for a new hearing. Its decision addresses several important issues related to Charter-related encampment litigation and emphasizes that Charter claims by encampment residents must be treated by courts seriously and with care. The Court of Appeal decision cautions judges against summarily dismissing the evidence of unhoused affiants even when they have mental health issues, are in active addiction or have a history of using controlled substances. The Court of Appeal also emphasizes the importance of cogent reasons and a sufficient “depth of analysis” given the gravity and public importance of issues relating to encampments (CA at para 40). The trial court decision (SC) had addressed several important issues: whether section 7 of the Charter establishes a right to shelter during the daytime, whether encampment evictions violate section 15 of the Charter, and whether unhoused individuals should be granted Charter damages for their removal from encampments. The Court of Appeal decision does not include substantive decisions on these points but does provide guidance on the types of questions that must be addressed in resolving them. This case comment synthesizes these key takeaways from the Heegsma case.

Grounds for (In)Equality: The Supreme Court of Canada Grapples with Intersectionality in Kanyinda

By: Jennifer Koshan and Jonnette Watson Hamilton

Case Commented on: Quebec (Attorney General) v Kanyinda, 2026 SCC 7 (CanLII)

PDF Version: Grounds for (In)Equality: The Supreme Court of Canada Grapples with Intersectionality in Kanyinda

Canada’s Evolving Right to Shelter: Region of Waterloo v Named Respondents & Persons Unknown

By: Anna J. Lund and Sarah Buhler

Case Commented On: The Regional Municipality of Waterloo v Named Respondents and Persons Unknown, 2026 ONSC 2971 (CanLII)

PDF Version: Canada’s Evolving Right to Shelter: Region of Waterloo v Named Respondents & Persons Unknown

On May 21, 2026, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (the Court) released its decision in The Regional Municipality of Waterloo v Named Respondents and Persons Unknown, 2026 ONSC 2971 (CanLII) (the Decision). The Decision considered the constitutionality of a regional government bylaw that sought to remove residents from an encampment. Housing rights advocates are lauding the Decision as a significant step forward in terms of courts recognizing the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (the Charter) as providing legal protections for the rights of unhoused Canadians, as well as its specific reliance on principles from international human rights law. This case comment provides a brief overview of the Decision, highlighting some of the key developments including:

The Minority Report on Electoral Districts: Will the Law Protect Alberta from UCP Gerrymandering?

By: Shaun Fluker

Report Commented On: Alberta Electoral Boundaries Commission Final Report (March 2026)

PDF Version: The Minority Report on Electoral Districts: Will the Law Protect Alberta from UCP Gerrymandering?

In a representative democracy, an elected representative is chosen by voters in their assigned electoral district. It goes without saying that the integrity of the process used to determine electoral districts is essential to a functional representative democracy. Any whiff of partisan influence on the process will poison the legitimacy of electoral outcomes, raising the spectre that electoral districts were drawn to ensure a particular result on voting day. This is known as “gerrymandering”. Political commentators (see here and here and here) have described the minority report issued by the two UCP-appointed members of the 2025-2026 Alberta Electoral Boundaries Commission as classic gerrymandering. We are not quite there yet because it remains to be seen whether the minority report will be implemented by the UCP government. This post describes the content of the Electoral Boundaries Commission report submitted to the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly on March 23, 2026 (the “Report”) and explores what legal guardrails exist to prevent gerrymandering from infecting Alberta’s democracy.

Back to School Act Survives Injunction Application

By: Jennifer Koshan

Case Commented On: Alberta Teachers Association v Alberta (AG), 2026 ABKB 190

PDF Version: Back to School Act Survives Injunction Application

On March 13, 2026, Justice Douglas R. Mah denied the application of the Alberta Teachers Association (ATA) for an interlocutory injunction to suspend operation of the Back to School Act, SA 2025, c B-05 (BSA). Background on this legislation and the Alberta government’s use of the Charter’s notwithstanding clause to override the teachers’ rights to collectively bargain and strike appears in earlier ABlawg posts here and here. This post will discuss Justice Mah’s reasons, including his commentary on the role of judges in a constitutional democracy. This commentary is a sign of the times in Alberta, with the government posing threats to the rule of law and judges feeling compelled to speak out and defend their role. And it is not just the Alberta government seeking to exert more control over the judiciary. On March 24, Alberta was joined by the governments of Saskatchewan, Ontario, and Quebec in calling for a greater say for the provinces in the selection of federally appointed judges. The provinces’ letter to Prime Minister Mark Carney came during a week when the Supreme Court of Canada is hearing what many consider to be the most important constitutional case since the Charter came into effect in 1982, English Montreal School Board, et al v Attorney General of Quebec, et al, 2025 CanLII 2818 (SCC) (EMSB). EMSB involves foundational issues about the powers of judges after a government has invoked the Charter’s notwithstanding clause, section 33. As I will discuss, the EMSB case played a key role in Justice Mah’s decision.

Page 1 of 2

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén